Montpelier, Vermont | Insurance Defense

Reported Decisions

McNall v. Town of Westford, Opinion No. 8-19WC (May 10, 2019)

Clayton v. J.C. Penney Corporation, 2017 VT 87

Conant v. Entergy Corporation, 2016 VT 74

Labate v. Rutland Hospital and Cancio-Bello, 2015 VT 128

In re Programmatic Changes to the Standard-Offer Program and Investigation into the Establishment of Standard-Offer Prices under the Sustainably Priced Energy Enterprise Development (SPEED) Program, 2014 VT 29

Korda v. Chicago Ins. Co., 2006 VT 81

Stoll v. Burlington Elec. Dept., 2009 VT 61

Smith v. Parrott, 2003 VT 64

Pirdair v. Medical Center Hospital of Vermont, 173 Vt. 411

T. Copeland & Sons, Inc. v. Kansa General Ins., 171 Vt. 18

Investment Properties , Inc. v. Lyttle, 169 Vt. 487

TBH By and Through Howard v. Meyer, 716 A.2d 31

Villeneuve, In re, 709 A.2d 1067

State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Roberts, 166 Vt. 452, 697 A.2d 667

Webb v. Navistar Intern. Transp. Corp., 166 Vt. 119, 692 A.2d 343

Bryan, In re, 164 Vt. 589, 674 A.2d 793

Breslauer v. Fayston School Dist., 163 Vt. 416, 659 A.2d 1129

UNUM Life Ins. Co. of America, In re, 162 Vt. 201, 647 A.2d 708

Campbell v. Manchester Bd. of School Directors, 161 Vt. 441, 641 A.2d 352

Abbiati v. Buttura & Sons, Inc., 161 Vt. 314, 639 A.2d 988

Hudson v. Town of East Montpelier, 161 Vt. 168, 638 A.2d 561

Shaw v. Dutton Berry Farm, 160 Vt. 594, 632 A.2d 18

Bashara v. Corliss, 161 Vt. 1, 632 A.2d 30

Putney School, Inc. v. Schaaf, 157 Vt. 396, 599 A.2d 322

Chater v. Central Vermont Hosp., 155 Vt. 230, 583 A.2d 889

Fancher v. Benson, 154 Vt. 583, 580 A.2d 51

The Children’s Store v. Cody Enterprises, Inc., 154 Vt. 634, 580 A.2d 206

Creighton v. Town of Windsor, 154 Vt. 348, 577 A.2d 681

Wolfe v. Yudichak, 153 Vt. 235, 571 A.2d 592

Goodrich v. U.S. Fidelity and Guar. Co., 152 Vt. 590, 568 A.2d 385

Center v. Mad River Corp., 151 Vt. 408, 561 A.2d 90

George v. Graham, 151 Vt. 527, 561 A.2d 1361

McCormack v. State, 150 Vt. 443, 553 A.2d 566

Pella Products, Inc. v. Krutak, 150 Vt. 81, 549 A.2d 1059

Segerstrom v. Knott, 149 Vt. 391, 543 A.2d 706

Sutfin v. Southworth, 149 Vt. 67, 539 A.2d 986

Hartman v. Ouellette Plumbing & Heating Corp., 146 Vt. 443, 507 A.2d 952

Segerstrom v. Wells, 146 Vt. 314, 501 A.2d 1193

Circus Studios, Ltd. v. Tufo, 145 Vt. 219, 485 A.2d 1261

Behn v. Northeast Appraisal Co., Inc., 145 Vt. 101, 483 A.2d 604

Montgomery v. Brinver Corp., 142 Vt. 461, 457 A.2d 644

Perkins v. Windsor Hosp. Corp., 142 Vt. 305, 455 A.2d 810

Campbell v. Heinrich Savelberg, Inc., 139 Vt. 31, 421 A.2d 1291

Holmquist v. Mental Health Services of Southeastern Vermont, 139 Vt. 1, 420 A.2d 108

Jones, Application of, 138 Vt. 223, 415 A.2d 202

South Burlington School Dist. v. Calcagni-Frazier-Zajchowski Architects, Inc., 138 Vt. 33, 410 A.2d 1359

Houghton v. Leinwohl, 135 Vt. 380, 376 A.2d 733

Commercial Union Ins. Co. v. City of Montpelier, 134 Vt. 184, 353 A.2d 344

Downer v. Gourlay, 133 Vt. 544, 349 A.2d 707

Teitelbaum v. Merklinger, 133 Vt. 148, 333 A.2d 91

Merrill v. University of Vermont, 133 Vt. 101, 329 A.2d 635

Weeks v. Burnor, 132 Vt. 603, 326 A.2d 138

Baird v. Eldredge, 132 Vt. 618, 326 A.2d 171

Duval v. Diamondstone, 132 Vt. 176, 315 A.2d 498

Laird Properties New England Land Syndicate v. Mad River Corp.,131 Vt. 268, 305 A.2d 562

Bresette v. Bresette, 130 Vt. 414, 296 A.2d 185

Crocker v. Brandt, 130 Vt. 349, 293 A.2d 541

Graves v. Town of Waitsfield, 130 Vt. 292, 292 A.2d 247

Leech v. Munn, 129 Vt. 575, 285 A.2d 706

Hemco, Inc., Application of, 129 Vt. 534, 283 A.2d 246

Walker Process Equipment Co. v. Cooley Bldg. Corp., 129 Vt. 333, 278 A.2d 714

Kerr v. Rollins, 128 Vt. 507, 266 A.2d 804

McBrine v. Fraser, 128 Vt. 514, 266 A.2d 809

Caledonia Sand & Gravel Co. v. Campbell, 128 Vt. 182, 260 A.2d 221

Rodgers v. Kelley, 128 Vt. 146, 259 A.2d 784

East Montpelier Development Corp. v. Barre Trust Co., 127 Vt. 491, 253 A.2d 131

Heath v. Orlandi, 127 Vt. 204, 243 A.2d 792

Banker v. Dodge, 126 Vt. 534, 237 A.2d 121

Savard v. Cody Chevrolet, Inc., 126 Vt. 405, 234 A.2d 656

Central Cab, Inc. v. Ironside, 126 Vt. 356, 230 A.2d 790

Griffin v. Griffin, 125 Vt. 425, 217 A.2d 400

John v. Fernandez, 124 Vt. 346, 205 A.2d 552

Smith v. Blow & Cote, Inc., 124 Vt. 64, 196 A.2d 489

Rivard v. Roy, 124 Vt. 32, 196 A.2d 497

Cody Chevrolet, Inc. v. Royer, 123 Vt. 389, 189 A.2d 554

Jones v. Lavanway, 123 Vt. 284, 187 A.2d 346

Jewell v. Olson Const. Co., 122 Vt. 434, 175 A.2d 509

Rae v. Green Mountain Boys Camp, 122 Vt. 437, 175 A.2d 800

Tracy v. Massachusetts Bonding & Ins. Co., 121 Vt. 371, 159 A.2d 86

Langevin v. Gilman, 121 Vt. 440, 159 A.2d 340

Benoit v. Marvin, 120 Vt. 201, 138 A.2d 312

Standard Register Co. v. Greenberg, 120 Vt. 112, 132 A.2d 174

State v. Malmquist, 114 Vt. 96, 40 A.2d 534

City of Montpelier v. Town of Calais, 114 Vt. 5, 39 A.2d 350

Brooks v. Holmes, 113 Vt. 456, 35 A.2d 374

City of Montpelier v. Town of Sharon, 113 Vt. 315, 34 A.2d 116

State v. Levy, 113 Vt. 374, 34 A.2d 370

Long v. Leonard, 113 Vt. 258, 32 A.2d 679

Nelson v. Travelers Ins. Co., 113 Vt. 86, 30 A.2d 75

Kerin v. Coates, 112 Vt. 466, 28 A.2d 382

White v. Hight, 112 Vt. 420, 26 A.2d 86

Boutwell’s Estate, In re, 112 Vt. 159, 22 A.2d 157

Moore v. Union Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 112 Vt. 218, 22 A.2d 503

Gero v. John Hancock Mut. Life Ins. Co., 111 Vt. 462, 18 A.2d 154

Kerr & Elliott v. Green Mountain Mut. Fire Ins. Co., 111 Vt. 502, 18 A.2d 164

Wetmore v. B. W. Hooker Co., 111 Vt. 519, 18 A.2d 181

Dieter v. Scott, 110 Vt. 376, 9 A.2d 95

Ex parte Thompson, 111 Vt. 7, 9 A.2d 107

F.I. Somers & Sons v. Le Clerc, 110 Vt. 408, 8 A.2d 663

State v. Elks Club of Montpelier, 110 Vt. 397, 8 A.2d 678

Montpelier & Wells River R.R. v. Caldbeck-Cosgrove Corp., 110 Vt. 390, 8 A.2d 681

Laird v. State of Vermont Highway Dept., 110 Vt. 195, 3 A.2d 552

Weiner v. Prudential Ins. Co. of America, 110 Vt. 22, 1 A.2d 708

Johnson v. Moore, 109 Vt. 282, 196 A. 246

Luce v. Chandler, 109 Vt. 275, 195 A. 246

Tyrrell v. Prudential Ins. Co. of America, 109 Vt. 6, 192 A. 184

Coral Gables v. Christopher, 108 Vt. 414, 189 A. 147

Shea v. Pilette, 108 Vt. 446, 189 A. 154

Shea v. Pilette, 108 Vt. 457, 189 A. 159

Healy v. Moore, 108 Vt. 324, 187 A. 679

Healy v. Moore, 108 Vt. 351, 187 A. 692

Hutchinson v. Knowles, 108 Vt. 195, 184 A. 705

Hutchinson v. Knowles, 108 Vt. 208, 184 A. 711

Prouty’s Estate, In re, 107 Vt. 504, 181 A. 138

Courtney v. Prudential Ins. Co. of America, 107 Vt. 491, 180 A. 894

Pellon v. Connecticut General Life Ins. Co., 107 Vt. 129, 178 A. 902

Dyar Sales & Machinery Co. v. Bleiler, 106 Vt. 425, 175 A. 27

Colgate v. Harvey, 107 Vt. 28, 175 A. 352

De Gray v. Miller Bros. Const. Co., 106 Vt. 259, 173 A. 556

D’Amato v. Donatoni, 105 Vt. 496, 168 A. 564

Pellon v. Connecticut General Life Ins. Co., 105 Vt. 508, 168 A. 701

Northern Trust Co. v. Perry, 105 Vt. 524, 168 A. 710

State v. Waite, 105 Vt. 265, 166 A. 4

Vermont Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v. Van Dyke, 105 Vt. 257, 165 A. 906

Green Mountain Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v. Van Dyke, 105 Vt. 264, 165 A. 909

Prouty’s Estate, In re, 105 Vt. 66, 163 A. 566

Price v. Holden, 104 Vt. 504, 162 A. 376

University of Vt. and State Agr. College v. Ward, 104 Vt. 239, 158 A. 773

Beatty v. Dunn, 103 Vt. 439, 157 A. 823

Jones v. Knapp, 104 Vt. 5, 156 A. 399

Beatty v. Dunn, 103 Vt. 340, 154 A. 770

Goodwin v. Gaston, 103 Vt. 357, 154 A. 772

Neill v. Ward, 103 Vt. 117, 153 A. 219

Retail Merchants’ Business Expansion Co. v. Randall, 103 Vt. 268, 153 A. 357

Williamson v. Clark, 103 Vt. 288, 153 A. 448

Jennings v. Gallagher, 103 Vt. 169, 152 A. 802

Cano v. Central Vermont Ry. Co., 102 Vt. 161, 147 A. 276

Foss v. Waite, 102 Vt. 260, 147 A. 351

Stewart v. Bleau’s Estate, 102 Vt. 273, 147 A. 692

Bundy v. State of Vermont Highway Dept., 102 Vt. 84, 146 A. 68

Pelow v. State of Vermont Highway Department, 102 Vt. 90, 146 A. 71

Town of Duxbury v. Town of Williamstown, 102 Vt. 94, 145 A. 872

F.A. Jewett & Son v. Smardon, 101 Vt. 488, 144 A. 683

Burleson v. Fox, 101 Vt. 225, 143 A. 298

Catto v. Liberty Granite Co., 101 Vt. 143, 141 A. 684

People’s Nat. Bank v. Brunelle, 101 Vt. 42, 140 A. 160

Saund v. Saund, 100 Vt. 387, 138 A. 867

Johnson v. Learie, 100 Vt. 308, 137 A. 205

Saund v. Saund, 100 Vt. 176, 136 A. 22

Murphy v. McMahon, 100 Vt. 86, 135 A. 3

Johnson v. Saindow, 99 Vt. 436, 134 A. 585

Reed v. Rowell, 100 Vt. 41, 134 A. 641

Le Febvre’s Adm’r v. Central Vermont Ry. Co., 99 Vt. 366, 133 A. 359

Capital Garage Co. v. Powell, 99 Vt. 244, 131 A. 10

Hopkins v. Veo, 98 Vt. 433, 129 A. 157

Cooley v. Hatch, 97 Vt. 484, 124 A. 589

G.R. Bianchi Granite Co. v. Terre Haute Monument Co., 91 Vt. 177, 99 A. 875

Wilbur v. Town of Calais, 90 Vt. 335, 98 A. 913

Pocket v. Almon, 90 Vt. 10, 96 A. 421

Leno v. Stewart, 89 Vt. 286, 95 A. 539

Miller v. Holmes, 89 Vt. 261, 95 A. 541

Howland Bros. & Cave v. Barre Sav. Bank & Trust Co., 89 Vt. 290, 95 A. 679

Canning v. Canning, 88 Vt. 522, 93 A. 259

Bondi v. Mackay, 87 Vt. 271, 89 A. 228

George v. Consolidated Lighting Co., 87 Vt. 411, 89 A. 635

Sanborn v. Village of Enosburg Falls, 87 Vt. 479, 89 A. 746

Davidson v. Whitehill, 87 Vt. 499, 89 A. 1081

Canning v. Canning, 87 Vt. 492, 89 A. 1088

Howland Bros. & Cave v. Barre Sav. Bank & Trust Co., 87 Vt. 181, 88 A. 732

Barnes v. Albert, 87 Vt. 251, 88 A. 815

Boville v. Dalton Paper Mills, 86 Vt. 305, 85 A. 623

Allen Lumber Co. v. Higuera, 86 Vt. 453, 85 A. 979

Duggan v. Heaphy, 85 Vt. 515, 83 A. 726

Wood v. City of Montpelier, 85 Vt. 467, 82 A. 671

McKane v. Gordon & Hoar, 85 Vt. 253, 81 A. 637

State v. Morse, 84 Vt. 387, 80 A. 189

Moore v. Duke, 84 Vt. 401, 80 A. 194

State v. Haskell, 84 Vt. 429, 79 A. 852

Bacon v. Boston & M.R.R., 83 Vt. 421, 76 A. 128

Pierson v. Huntington, 82 Vt. 482, 74 A. 88

Tudor v. Tudor, 80 Vt. 220, 67 A. 539

Francis Batchelder & Co. v. Wedge, 80 Vt. 353, 67 A. 828

State v. Niles, 78 Vt. 266, 62 A. 795

Payne v. Sheets, 75 Vt. 335, 55 A. 656

State v. Theriault, 70 Vt. 617, 41 A. 1030